Ditching
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the boot of my car!
Posts: 5,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
One favourite saying of mine is " If you never push the boundaries you will never find what lies beyond ! ". So true in every field of life but in pushing those boundaries make sure the beyond is something you are prepared for as the beyond which is relatively unknown might be something which is more than you can handle.
Pace
Pace
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 3,325
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think Old Fat One has it. I used to regularly fly BPL - IOM in a fixed gear single; I wouldn't do it now. If the engine fails, you are almost certainly going to die. Maybe I'm older and wiser or just seen a bit more over the decades of aviating.
I can't rationalise flying single engine water these days. It goes against my aviation principle of 'always having an out'. If the engine fails over land I'm reasonably confident of living, even maybe walking away. I just can't trust my life to the bag of mechanical bits that comprise an engine and fuel system, knowing that if it fails (and they do as I know from experience!) I'll die.
I can't rationalise flying single engine water these days. It goes against my aviation principle of 'always having an out'. If the engine fails over land I'm reasonably confident of living, even maybe walking away. I just can't trust my life to the bag of mechanical bits that comprise an engine and fuel system, knowing that if it fails (and they do as I know from experience!) I'll die.
"Almost certainly" going to die is a bit strong. Even "probably" is too much. I think "quite likely" covers it. If you are on the ball, have an ELT and a good dingy it is could be "maybe".
Anyway, as has been done to death in another thread, if you remember to maintain your engine and put fuel in it, it is very unlikely to let you down.
I fly SE in all weathers and times of day over water and expect to die in bed.
Anyway, as has been done to death in another thread, if you remember to maintain your engine and put fuel in it, it is very unlikely to let you down.
I fly SE in all weathers and times of day over water and expect to die in bed.
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 3,325
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
if you remember to maintain your engine and put fuel in it, it is very unlikely to let you down.
A dingy might help. If you've room for one in the aircraft you fly.
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: UK
Age: 85
Posts: 697
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am surprised that no-one has told you to make a check list.
I made a check list to suit my own aircraft for when I was over the sea.
I assumed that should an engine fail, I would be at a sensible height over the water and would therefore have quite a few minutes before getting down to ditching level.
Making the list was good in itself as it made me think specific to my own aircraft.
After basic engine failure checks I listed in order the things that might get muddled. Things like get your position from the GPS and write it down, call mayday then remove headset and get the rubber helmet of the wetsuit on. Get the rubber gloves on. Make sure the location beacon is handy and clipped to you not the aircraft, deal with passenger, make sure the door is unlatched.
I can't remember all the things but I know that there would be plenty of time between cruising height and water level to do things methodically.
Getting down to water level will be the easy bit it is entering the water that it is all about. Your screen will likely come in and you may have problems getting out. If you prepare yourself for the cold shock and an upside down position you will be less surprised when it happens. Remember your engine will very likely try to take the craft down so getting out is important.
I have never been impressed by inflatable dinghies unless they get outside by themselves, can you imaging trying to heave one from the back seat of a PA28 for example and then it not being in the way when you try to get out. A full immersion suit is the only way.
So among your book of checklists have a 'ditching' checklist.
Off to Jersey...
I made a check list to suit my own aircraft for when I was over the sea.
I assumed that should an engine fail, I would be at a sensible height over the water and would therefore have quite a few minutes before getting down to ditching level.
Making the list was good in itself as it made me think specific to my own aircraft.
After basic engine failure checks I listed in order the things that might get muddled. Things like get your position from the GPS and write it down, call mayday then remove headset and get the rubber helmet of the wetsuit on. Get the rubber gloves on. Make sure the location beacon is handy and clipped to you not the aircraft, deal with passenger, make sure the door is unlatched.
I can't remember all the things but I know that there would be plenty of time between cruising height and water level to do things methodically.
Getting down to water level will be the easy bit it is entering the water that it is all about. Your screen will likely come in and you may have problems getting out. If you prepare yourself for the cold shock and an upside down position you will be less surprised when it happens. Remember your engine will very likely try to take the craft down so getting out is important.
I have never been impressed by inflatable dinghies unless they get outside by themselves, can you imaging trying to heave one from the back seat of a PA28 for example and then it not being in the way when you try to get out. A full immersion suit is the only way.
So among your book of checklists have a 'ditching' checklist.
Off to Jersey...
Last edited by funfly; 20th Dec 2013 at 21:11.
You can't say there always has to be an 'out'. As soon as you are born you are always taking some sort of unavoidable risk, it simply depends what risk you are able/want to accept.
We will probably have to agree to disagree on this one.
We will probably have to agree to disagree on this one.
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the boot of my car!
Posts: 5,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Funfly
Very sensible advice! Noted the comment on getting the life raft out! In all the shock and confusion that is a very relevant point!
I mentioned jamming the door open in the glide down as water pressure can literally lock you in! Maybe part of that checklist should be jamming the door with the life raft so the door is kept open and the life raft the first thing out followed by the pilot/passengers (hardly discussed) hanging onto it
Pace
Very sensible advice! Noted the comment on getting the life raft out! In all the shock and confusion that is a very relevant point!
I mentioned jamming the door open in the glide down as water pressure can literally lock you in! Maybe part of that checklist should be jamming the door with the life raft so the door is kept open and the life raft the first thing out followed by the pilot/passengers (hardly discussed) hanging onto it
Pace
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 3,325
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You can't say there always has to be an 'out'.
In aviation, which is what we're talking about, you should always have an 'out' for foreseeable possible happenings. Obviously if a wing falls off without pilot provocation it just wasn't your day, and there wasn't anything you could have done about it except not fly.
But wings don't just 'fall off'. Perfectly well maintained engines can, and do, fail however. Which is why we train for it happening.
Setting off across the sea behind a single engine is a deliberate aviation decision for which there is no 'out' if the engine fails. Many pilots are happy with that. I used to be and often did it.
I'm not now as I can no longer rationalise betting my life on the engine not failing (every egg in one basket - game over if it doesn't pay off), even though the odds are very greatly that it will continue to run just fine.
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: UK
Posts: 217
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This is what it comes down to, one person's calculated risk isn't the same as anothers. We could discuss this until the cows come home but at the end of the day, you are commander of the aircraft and the risk you are willing to take is entirely appropriate for you. It may not be appropriate for someone else but then they are not the commander of your aircraft.
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 3,325
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Very true! In my case I am the same person who once upon a time was OK with a BPL - IOM crossing in a SEP, but today is not.
It's all down as to whether you rationalise the risk as acceptable, or not. I have absolutely no problem at all about pilots who do rationalise it as acceptable. I used to be one!
It's all down as to whether you rationalise the risk as acceptable, or not. I have absolutely no problem at all about pilots who do rationalise it as acceptable. I used to be one!
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the boot of my car!
Posts: 5,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dave
I fully understand your right to determine the level of risk you are prepared to take and as other posters I used to do water crossings in singles myself until I regularly flew twins! After that and a few engine problems I started seeing water crossings in a single in a different light!
One question? While your prepared to take that risk for yourself what do you do with passengers take that risk decision for them too ?
Pace
I fully understand your right to determine the level of risk you are prepared to take and as other posters I used to do water crossings in singles myself until I regularly flew twins! After that and a few engine problems I started seeing water crossings in a single in a different light!
One question? While your prepared to take that risk for yourself what do you do with passengers take that risk decision for them too ?
Pace
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: UK
Posts: 217
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Pace
I've never crossed water with anything other than qualified pilots on board where we have discussed the risk and done a drill for a possible ditching. Would I take non pilot pax? No. Having said that I would have no qualms about doing Dover- Cap GN at 6,000 or above (6,500 being class A of course at that point) with non pilot pax as that's within a glide of land/beach.
Edit: As an aside, I did a bit of a Scotland tour in May with a flying buddy of mine in a 28. The last leg was Leuchars-Waddington which he flew. The leg from Anstruther-Dunbar across the Firth is 15 nm, only 2 miles less than Dover-Cap GN. Taking off from Leuchars we were only at around 2,000 and climbing when we crossed the coast and never gave it a second thought as it was 'just' an estuary.
I've never crossed water with anything other than qualified pilots on board where we have discussed the risk and done a drill for a possible ditching. Would I take non pilot pax? No. Having said that I would have no qualms about doing Dover- Cap GN at 6,000 or above (6,500 being class A of course at that point) with non pilot pax as that's within a glide of land/beach.
Edit: As an aside, I did a bit of a Scotland tour in May with a flying buddy of mine in a 28. The last leg was Leuchars-Waddington which he flew. The leg from Anstruther-Dunbar across the Firth is 15 nm, only 2 miles less than Dover-Cap GN. Taking off from Leuchars we were only at around 2,000 and climbing when we crossed the coast and never gave it a second thought as it was 'just' an estuary.
Last edited by Dave Wilson; 22nd Dec 2013 at 21:50.
To each their own as you say.
I have crossed the Atlantic 5 and a half times in my Robin along with various other oceans. I think it is a good enough risk to do occasionally.
I still expect to die in bed.
I have crossed the Atlantic 5 and a half times in my Robin along with various other oceans. I think it is a good enough risk to do occasionally.
I still expect to die in bed.
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: In the boot of my car!
Posts: 5,982
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dave
Crossing the channel at Dover is not such a big deal because of the volume of boats and ships
Your biggest danger is probably being run over by one not looking
I am more talking about longer crossing over more inhospitable and deserted seas!
I have done limited ferry work always multi and jet never single
When you see the vast expanse of ocean between the UK and Iceland the thought of some guy way below trundling along at 90 kts in a small piston is mind boggling! They are Either very brave or very stupid or both but I do admire them
Pace
Crossing the channel at Dover is not such a big deal because of the volume of boats and ships
Your biggest danger is probably being run over by one not looking
I am more talking about longer crossing over more inhospitable and deserted seas!
I have done limited ferry work always multi and jet never single
When you see the vast expanse of ocean between the UK and Iceland the thought of some guy way below trundling along at 90 kts in a small piston is mind boggling! They are Either very brave or very stupid or both but I do admire them
Pace
They are Either very brave or very stupid or both
I have had great experiences and seen some amazing things between Stornoway and Baffin island. Well worth a very very slight chance of death.